“Should I buy an annuity or stay in drawdown?” — it’s the single most common question I’m asked by UK expats here in the Algarve. And it’s a fair one. Get the answer right and you’ve locked in a comfortable retirement income for life. Get it wrong and you could be running short of money in your eighties, or paying far more tax than you needed to.

The truth is there isn’t one universally correct answer. The annuity vs drawdown decision for a UK expat living in Portugal involves moving parts that don’t apply to retirees back in Britain — currency exposure, Portuguese tax rules, your NHR status (or lack of it), and the very real practical question of how UK insurers handle paying an income to someone with a Portuguese address. In this guide I’ll walk you through the trade-offs as I’d discuss them with a client over coffee in Lagos.

Annuity vs Drawdown: The Quick Definitions

Before we get into the expat-specific bits, let’s make sure we’re talking about the same thing.

An annuity is an insurance product. You hand over a chunk of your pension pot to an insurance company, and in exchange they pay you a guaranteed income for the rest of your life (or for a fixed period, depending on the type you choose). Once it’s set up, you’ve made a permanent decision — you can’t change your mind and ask for the lump sum back.

Flexi-access drawdown (which simply means taking flexible amounts from your pension pot) keeps your money invested in a SIPP or personal pension and lets you withdraw whatever you want, whenever you want, after age 55 (rising to 57 in 2028). Your pot stays exposed to investment markets — it can grow, but it can also fall — and when you die, whatever’s left passes to your beneficiaries.

For decades, drawdown has been the default option for most UK retirees thanks to pension freedoms introduced in 2015. But annuity rates have improved sharply in recent years as gilt yields recovered, and the conversation has rightly opened up again — particularly for expats who are weighing currency and tax considerations on top of everything else.

Why the Decision Looks Different When You Live in Portugal

Here’s where things get interesting. A retiree in Surrey choosing between annuity and drawdown is comparing two pounds-denominated income streams, both taxed in the UK. A retiree in Portugal is comparing two pounds-denominated income streams, both spent in euros, and both potentially taxed in Portugal under the UK-Portugal Double Taxation Treaty.

That changes the calculus in three important ways.

Currency risk. If you take an annuity in sterling and the pound weakens against the euro, your spending power in Portugal falls — and there’s nothing you can do about it because the income is fixed in pounds. With drawdown, you have more flexibility to time conversions, hold euro investments, or use a sterling-to-euro hedging strategy.

I covered the mechanics of currency risk in detail in my recent piece on currency risk for UK expats in Portugal — worth a read alongside this one.

Portuguese taxation. Under the treaty, most UK private pension income is taxable in Portugal as your country of residence. If you have NHR 1.0 with the 10% flat rate on foreign pensions, both annuity and drawdown income should fall into that bucket — no real difference there. But once NHR expires (or if you’re under NHR 2.0 / IFICI without pension income protection), drawdown income and annuity income are both taxed at standard Portuguese progressive rates, up to 48%. The key planning point is that you have more control over the timing with drawdown, which can matter a lot for managing your tax bracket year to year.

Practical insurer issues. Some UK annuity providers are reluctant to set up new annuities for non-UK residents, or will only pay into a UK bank account. Some drawdown providers are similarly fussy. This isn’t a deal-breaker but it does narrow your shortlist — and it’s something to check before you commit.

The Case for an Annuity

Annuities have a real PR problem. People hear “annuity” and think “rip-off product from 2008 paying 3%”. That’s outdated. With base rates and gilt yields where they’ve been recently, a healthy 65-year-old can typically secure an inflation-linked annuity yielding meaningfully more than that, and a level annuity considerably more again.

The strongest argument for an annuity is certainty. If you sleep badly worrying about market crashes or the possibility of running out of money, an annuity removes that anxiety completely. Once it’s in place, the income arrives every month for the rest of your life, full stop. For clients with no other guaranteed income beyond the State Pension, this peace of mind can be priceless.

Annuities also work well when you’re not a confident investor and don’t want to be one. Drawdown demands ongoing decisions: how much to withdraw, what to invest in, when to rebalance, how to respond to a market drop. Some retirees relish that engagement; others find it stressful and would rather hand it off entirely.

If you have a known health condition that reduces your life expectancy, an enhanced (or impaired-life) annuity can pay considerably more than a standard one. Conditions like type 2 diabetes, high blood pressure, heart disease and a history of smoking can all qualify. I’ve had clients secure 20–40% higher annuity rates this way. Many people don’t realise this and accept a standard quote that vastly underprices them.

The downsides? It’s irreversible. The capital is gone — you can’t change your mind, you can’t pass the lump sum to your kids, and if you die early without the right death benefits attached, the insurer keeps a large chunk of your money. That last point is what puts most clients off.

The Case for Drawdown

Drawdown’s biggest selling point is flexibility. You decide how much to take and when. Want to take more in your “go-go” years of early retirement and less later? Easy. Want to take nothing in a year your other income is high to manage tax brackets? Done. Want to leave a lump sum to your children? Whatever’s in the pot when you die generally passes to your nominated beneficiaries — usually outside your estate for UK inheritance tax purposes (though this is changing from April 2027, see my note below).

For a UK expat in Portugal, drawdown’s tax-timing flexibility is genuinely valuable. A common scenario: in a year you sell a UK rental property and have a big capital gain, you might withdraw less from your pension to keep your overall Portuguese tax position manageable. In a leaner year, you can withdraw more. You can’t do this with an annuity — it pays what it pays, regardless.

Drawdown also keeps the pot invested, which means it can grow. Over a 25-year retirement, even modest investment returns can substantially extend the longevity of a pot. Of course, the markets can also go the other way, particularly in the early years of retirement (the “sequence of returns” risk), which is why how you draw matters as much as what you’re invested in.

The downsides are real: you bear the investment risk, you bear the longevity risk (the pot can run out), and you have to make ongoing decisions. For someone who isn’t going to engage with their pension or pay an adviser to do so, drawdown can quietly go wrong over a decade or two without anyone noticing until it’s too late.

The Hybrid Approach Most People Should Consider

Here’s the answer I give most often, and it surprises people: you don’t have to pick one. For many of my clients, the right structure is a blended approach.

The idea is straightforward: use part of your pot to buy enough guaranteed income — combined with your State Pension and any defined benefit pensions — to cover your essential expenses (rent or mortgage, groceries, utilities, healthcare, basic transport). Then leave the remainder in drawdown for everything else: travel, gifts to family, replacing the car, the unexpected.

This way you get the psychological floor of guaranteed income for the basics, and the flexibility, growth potential and inheritance benefits of drawdown for the discretionary spending. You’re not forced to invest the rent money in a market you can’t time, and you’re not handing over the whole lot to an insurer who’ll keep what you don’t spend.

How much to annuitise depends on your essentials, your other guaranteed income, your attitude to risk and your wider wealth picture. As a rough guide, I find clients are comfortable annuitising 25–40% of a typical pot to cover essentials, with the balance kept in drawdown — but every situation is different.

What About QROPS, SIPPs and Other Wrappers?

One thing worth flagging: the annuity vs drawdown decision sits inside the wrapper question. If you’ve transferred your UK pension to a QROPS, your options at retirement may differ from those of a UK SIPP holder. Most QROPS allow flexible drawdown, and some can purchase annuities, but the tax treatment and the post-five-year reporting rules to HMRC need careful navigation.

If you’ve kept your pension in the UK as a SIPP, you have the full menu of UK retirement options available, but you’re also subject to UK rules on tax-free lump sums, the new lump sum allowance regime and the upcoming 2027 inheritance tax changes. I covered the SIPP vs QROPS question in my earlier guide, which is worth reading if you haven’t yet decided how to hold the pot.

The 2027 Inheritance Tax Change You Need to Know About

From April 2027, most unused UK pension pots will fall inside a person’s estate for UK inheritance tax purposes — a meaningful change from the current treatment, where pensions generally sit outside the estate. This affects the calculus for drawdown specifically: previously one of drawdown’s strongest arguments was that whatever was left could pass to family largely free of UK IHT. After April 2027, that advantage narrows substantially.

Annuities, by contrast, don’t form part of an estate (the income simply ceases on death, unless you’ve added a guarantee period or spouse’s pension). So the playing field is becoming a little more level.

This change is worth factoring in if you have a large pot and significant assets above the UK nil-rate band. The detail will depend on the final regulations, which HMRC continues to refine — see the government’s published guidance for the current position.

How I’d Approach the Decision With a Client

When a client asks me which option is right, I run through five questions before I’ll give a view.

1. What are your essential monthly expenses in Portugal, in euros? This sets the floor of guaranteed income you actually need.
2. What guaranteed income do you already have? UK State Pension, any defined benefit pensions, rental income that’s reliable, partner’s pensions. Add these up first — you may need less annuity than you think.
3. What’s your appetite for managing investments through retirement? Be honest. If the answer is “none, I just want it to work”, that’s a clue.
4. What’s your health and family longevity picture? This affects whether enhanced annuities apply and how long the pot needs to last.
5. What’s your tax position and NHR status? Different tax positions favour different income-shaping strategies.

Only once we’ve answered those five do I model the options. We’ll typically run three scenarios — full drawdown, full annuity, and a hybrid — projecting income, tax and bequest outcomes over 25–30 years with a few different market and longevity assumptions. The right answer usually becomes obvious once you see the numbers in front of you.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I buy a UK annuity if I live in Portugal?

Yes, but the provider list is narrower than for UK residents. Some major UK annuity providers will issue annuities to expats and pay into a Portuguese bank account; others insist on a UK bank account or won’t take overseas applicants at all. It’s worth working with an adviser who can shop the whole-of-market for you rather than going direct to one provider.

Will my UK annuity income be taxed in the UK or Portugal?

Under the UK-Portugal Double Taxation Treaty, most private pension and annuity income is taxable in your country of residence — Portugal — provided you’ve completed the formalities (DT-Individual form, NT tax code in the UK). UK government service pensions are an exception and remain taxable in the UK. Always confirm the position for your specific arrangement before relying on a general rule.

Can I take a 25% tax-free lump sum and put the rest into drawdown?

Yes — this is the most common starting point in the UK. The wrinkle for expats is that Portugal does not necessarily recognise the UK’s 25% tax-free lump sum as tax-free under Portuguese rules; the treatment depends on your residency status, NHR position, and how the lump sum is structured. I covered this in detail in my dedicated tax-free lump sum guide.

What happens to my drawdown pot if I die?

Currently (until April 2027) your pension passes to your nominated beneficiaries largely outside your UK estate, with income tax payable by them at their marginal rate if you die after 75, or tax-free if you die before. From April 2027, most unused pension pots will be brought into the IHT net. Always keep your nomination of beneficiaries up to date — it’s the single most important piece of admin people forget.

Can I change my mind once I’ve bought an annuity?

Almost certainly not. Annuities are sold on the basis that the decision is permanent, and there’s no general right to cancel after the cooling-off period. This is the single biggest reason to take advice before annuitising — you want to be sure before you sign.

What to Do Next

Annuity vs drawdown isn’t really a binary choice for most UK expats in Portugal — it’s a question of how much of each, in what order, and using which wrapper. The right blend depends on your essentials, your other income, your health, your tax position and your family situation. There’s no shortcut to working it through properly.

If you’d like to discuss how this affects your personal situation, get in touch with our team. We specialise in helping UK expats in Portugal make the most of their pensions and retirement income.

Matthew Renier is a Chartered Financial Adviser at Arthur Browns Wealth Management, based in the Algarve, Portugal. He has over a decade of experience helping British expats manage their pensions and financial planning across borders.

Contact us